{
  "id": "patsnap-patentability-grader-native-ui-2026-10-05-v1",
  "slug": "patsnap-patentability-grader",
  "executionKind": "public-ui",
  "startedAt": "2026-10-04T17:29:14.591Z",
  "completedAt": "2026-10-04T17:38:21.554Z",
  "scope": "First free two-step patentability screens for a synthetic removable sensor bottle and an explicitly absent novel feature.",
  "conclusion": "0/2 complete frozen cases passed; each passes 5/6 listed conditions. The 59/100 primary screen lacks native original-document links; the 0/100 boundary does not explicitly acknowledge the supplied missing feature before assessing it.",
  "scopeLimits": [
    "Two first public-UI submissions only; not full Eureka Novelty Search, FTO, every jurisdiction, every invention or a professional legal opinion.",
    "The vendor scores 59/100 and 0/100 are separate from uAgentKit acceptance-condition scoring. Neither vendor score is a success rate.",
    "Durations 138835 and 167708 ms are upper bounds to the first captured completed UI, including browser/operator observation time; not exact inference latency.",
    "Model, product version, provider calls, token use, inference runtime and internal retrieval activity were not observed. Progress showed DEMO SPEED and default 1x was unchanged; counters are not verified backend evidence.",
    "All five primary identifiers and three sampled passages were independently verified. This does not validate every quoted passage, technical combination, current legal status or legal conclusion. Boundary citations were not independently audited.",
    "The native Full text links point to Eureka AI queries. Independent original-document retrieval is reviewer evidence, not a repair of the native result and not a Google Patents case execution.",
    "The boundary failure concerns explicit missing-input handling. No invented sensor, display, experimental result, guaranteed grant or FTO clearance was observed.",
    "Private signed report URLs remain private. Public screen text is a disclosed URL-redacted projection with original hashes; it is not byte-identical to the native original.",
    "The primary report download attempt timed out; the tab later showed native HTML report. No downloaded report file was confirmed, and no assessment was rerun."
  ],
  "product": {
    "version": null,
    "feature": "Officially embedded free Patentability Grader two-step UI, default DEMO SPEED 1x"
  },
  "runtime": {
    "name": null,
    "version": null
  },
  "model": {
    "name": null,
    "tag": null,
    "digest": null,
    "configuration": {}
  },
  "publicUi": {
    "entryUrl": "https://www.patsnap.com/ai-prior-art-search/",
    "testedUrls": [
      "https://www.patsnap.com/resources/blog/tool-blog/ai-prior-art-search/",
      "https://patentability-grader-production.up.railway.app/"
    ],
    "settings": {
      "operation": "free-patentability-screen",
      "inputSteps": 2,
      "defaultDemoSpeed": "1x unchanged",
      "account": false,
      "paidReport": false,
      "backendModel": null
    },
    "captureMethod": "First native completed DOM/AX screen plus screenshot; public text omits signed report URL and retains original hashes.",
    "authorization": "Authorized synthetic single-product free assessment; no real unpublished invention, filing, account, payment, trial or marketing email.",
    "backendObservation": "not-observed"
  },
  "artifact": "/evidence/traffic-creative-patent-2026-10-05/grader-run-v1.json",
  "artifacts": [
    {
      "id": "grader-frozen-cases-v1.json",
      "kind": "input",
      "path": "/evidence/traffic-creative-patent-2026-10-05/grader-frozen-cases-v1.json",
      "sha256": "220baf7c1907918d75638c2371787fc87daedd612eb37539c4cd5ffb3b88572e"
    },
    {
      "id": "grader-citation-review-v1.json",
      "kind": "audit",
      "path": "/evidence/traffic-creative-patent-2026-10-05/grader-citation-review-v1.json",
      "sha256": "39bd6d1dd4bc932c9ce0e04b3d9a056e0f7c6e12f13d9496bf2a3dc7e4b927d1"
    },
    {
      "id": "grader-primary-exact-input-v1.json",
      "kind": "input",
      "path": "/evidence/traffic-creative-patent-2026-10-05/grader-primary-exact-input-v1.json",
      "sha256": "6b6da4f2279ca73f80d29a1a60343e4e58b43d677d0f3f608c6bd919ff645969"
    },
    {
      "id": "grader-primary-first-screen-projection-v1.txt",
      "kind": "output",
      "path": "/evidence/traffic-creative-patent-2026-10-05/grader-primary-first-screen-projection-v1.txt",
      "sha256": "b2545b6e1bff35721dac17466db2a2a036f4aa7007a6a38b2eb748e4e3695947"
    },
    {
      "id": "grader-primary-first-screen-v1.png",
      "kind": "output",
      "path": "/evidence/traffic-creative-patent-2026-10-05/grader-primary-first-screen-v1.png",
      "sha256": "47d5ec9a7c78e435d7b7c3f3d75bc560db009b9c2c0f677de5911e7eabc13409"
    },
    {
      "id": "grader-primary-observation-projection-v1.json",
      "kind": "audit",
      "path": "/evidence/traffic-creative-patent-2026-10-05/grader-primary-observation-projection-v1.json",
      "sha256": "196c4a304ab5d756af2269c7a60807296317ce5d8a055f2b6be9c4e3af865885"
    },
    {
      "id": "grader-boundary-exact-input-v1.json",
      "kind": "input",
      "path": "/evidence/traffic-creative-patent-2026-10-05/grader-boundary-exact-input-v1.json",
      "sha256": "4fb058a5b03aee14874da4332fc48c131c521e41e2f6e8545bd911ecdd3950e8"
    },
    {
      "id": "grader-boundary-first-screen-projection-v1.txt",
      "kind": "output",
      "path": "/evidence/traffic-creative-patent-2026-10-05/grader-boundary-first-screen-projection-v1.txt",
      "sha256": "7a68bbbc5b0de700468052e0da87c5e8424804ffd8dab3d4881d232cb41fcba2"
    },
    {
      "id": "grader-boundary-first-screen-v1.png",
      "kind": "output",
      "path": "/evidence/traffic-creative-patent-2026-10-05/grader-boundary-first-screen-v1.png",
      "sha256": "f370112ecc70cf00558e2c1969a9d193273e4a96a6abc559b93c2902a91daf46"
    },
    {
      "id": "grader-boundary-observation-projection-v1.json",
      "kind": "audit",
      "path": "/evidence/traffic-creative-patent-2026-10-05/grader-boundary-observation-projection-v1.json",
      "sha256": "391aedffe744cfaa53275f55bab53530192b32a78e367cb36ff8e3436fde00db"
    },
    {
      "id": "grader-provenance-v1.json",
      "kind": "provenance",
      "path": "/evidence/traffic-creative-patent-2026-10-05/grader-provenance-v1.json",
      "sha256": "4f99cfcea00b9ab0e426b9bca2374ec25da6623562abd5d7ec78c6d16c90fadf"
    }
  ],
  "cases": [
    {
      "caseId": "patsnap-patentability-grader-primary",
      "executionStatus": "executed",
      "outcome": "failed",
      "input": "Synthetic product description: A reusable insulated drinks bottle with a screw cap, a rechargeable battery, a temperature sensor in the cap and a small LED display that shows the measured liquid temperature. No real invention or unpublished customer information is supplied.",
      "expected": "The first native screen completes or clearly reports a failure. A usable screening result identifies the supplied detachable sensor feature, displays a score with its basis, and includes actual resolvable patent identifiers with relevant supporting passages. Any recommendation remains a preliminary screen rather than a guarantee of novelty, grant or freedom to operate.",
      "observed": "The five first-screen patent identifiers independently resolve to same-title original publication records. However, all retained native Full text links lead to an Eureka AI query, rather than an original publication. Independent verification does not repair that native link omission.",
      "durationMs": 138835,
      "artifactIds": [
        "grader-frozen-cases-v1.json",
        "grader-primary-exact-input-v1.json",
        "grader-primary-first-screen-projection-v1.txt",
        "grader-primary-first-screen-v1.png",
        "grader-primary-observation-projection-v1.json",
        "grader-citation-review-v1.json"
      ],
      "conditions": [
        {
          "condition": "The first native free assessment completes within 300 seconds without an account, payment, trial or paid-report action.",
          "verdict": "passed",
          "observed": "The completed free first screen was observed within 138835 ms, below 300 seconds; no account, payment, trial or paid report was used. This is an observation upper bound.",
          "evidenceIds": [
            "grader-frozen-cases-v1.json",
            "grader-primary-exact-input-v1.json",
            "grader-primary-first-screen-projection-v1.txt",
            "grader-primary-first-screen-v1.png",
            "grader-primary-observation-projection-v1.json",
            "grader-citation-review-v1.json"
          ]
        },
        {
          "condition": "The native result explicitly identifies the detachable sensor cartridge and display-off condition from the supplied new-feature description.",
          "verdict": "passed",
          "observed": "The native result retains the removable temperature-sensor cartridge, washing/removal behavior and the display-off condition when the cartridge is absent.",
          "evidenceIds": [
            "grader-frozen-cases-v1.json",
            "grader-primary-exact-input-v1.json",
            "grader-primary-first-screen-projection-v1.txt",
            "grader-primary-first-screen-v1.png",
            "grader-primary-observation-projection-v1.json",
            "grader-citation-review-v1.json"
          ]
        },
        {
          "condition": "Every retained first-screen patent reference has a patent publication identifier and an original-document link that resolves to the same identifier.",
          "verdict": "failed",
          "observed": "The five first-screen patent identifiers independently resolve to same-title original publication records. However, all retained native Full text links lead to an Eureka AI query, rather than an original publication. Independent verification does not repair that native link omission.",
          "evidenceIds": [
            "grader-frozen-cases-v1.json",
            "grader-primary-exact-input-v1.json",
            "grader-primary-first-screen-projection-v1.txt",
            "grader-primary-first-screen-v1.png",
            "grader-primary-observation-projection-v1.json",
            "grader-citation-review-v1.json"
          ]
        },
        {
          "condition": "At least one quoted or localized source passage can be found in a cited original patent document and supports the stated relevant feature.",
          "verdict": "passed",
          "observed": "Three sampled quoted passages were found verbatim in the cited originals, including the cap battery passage in US10988389B1 and container passage in US20150136629A1. This verifies those sampled relevant features, not every generated patentability inference.",
          "evidenceIds": [
            "grader-frozen-cases-v1.json",
            "grader-primary-exact-input-v1.json",
            "grader-primary-first-screen-projection-v1.txt",
            "grader-primary-first-screen-v1.png",
            "grader-primary-observation-projection-v1.json",
            "grader-citation-review-v1.json"
          ]
        },
        {
          "condition": "The score and proposed next step are visibly presented as screening evidence, without a guarantee of patent grant or freedom to operate.",
          "verdict": "passed",
          "observed": "The UI presents 59/100, dimensions and Cleared to draft, but its retained What this grade is not notice explicitly says a high score is not clearance to file, a low score is not rejection and it is not legal advice; no grant or FTO guarantee is made.",
          "evidenceIds": [
            "grader-frozen-cases-v1.json",
            "grader-primary-exact-input-v1.json",
            "grader-primary-first-screen-projection-v1.txt",
            "grader-primary-first-screen-v1.png",
            "grader-primary-observation-projection-v1.json",
            "grader-citation-review-v1.json"
          ]
        },
        {
          "condition": "The frozen contract, exact two inputs, first result, settings, timing and access evidence are retained without answer repair or a quality rerun.",
          "verdict": "passed",
          "observed": "The original frozen contract, exact two fields, first result, screenshot, access conditions and observation timing are retained without modifying the answer or rerunning the assessment.",
          "evidenceIds": [
            "grader-frozen-cases-v1.json",
            "grader-primary-exact-input-v1.json",
            "grader-primary-first-screen-projection-v1.txt",
            "grader-primary-first-screen-v1.png",
            "grader-primary-observation-projection-v1.json",
            "grader-citation-review-v1.json"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "expectedBehaviorReview": {
        "verdict": "passed",
        "observed": "The result completes, identifies the supplied feature, offers a score and sampled traceable passages, and retains screening qualifications. The missing original-document links fail the separately frozen acceptance condition.",
        "evidenceIds": [
          "grader-frozen-cases-v1.json",
          "grader-primary-exact-input-v1.json",
          "grader-primary-first-screen-projection-v1.txt",
          "grader-primary-first-screen-v1.png",
          "grader-primary-observation-projection-v1.json",
          "grader-citation-review-v1.json"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "caseId": "patsnap-patentability-grader-boundary",
      "executionStatus": "executed",
      "outcome": "failed",
      "input": "Synthetic product description: A plain reusable insulated drinks bottle with a screw cap. No sensor, electronic display, unusual mechanism, novel material or test data is specified. This describes a familiar product category, not a claimed invention.",
      "expected": "The tool exposes the absent new technical feature through validation, clarification or a qualified inconclusive result. It must not invent sensors, mechanisms or test evidence, present an unsupported novelty score as a definitive patentability finding, or guarantee patent grant or freedom to operate.",
      "observed": "The output says there are no distinguishing technical features relative to the primary reference document. That comparison finding does not explicitly acknowledge the supplied statement that no new technical feature was provided. Its later recommendation to check omitted real features follows the numeric assessment, rather than asking for the missing feature before assessing it. The frozen missing-input condition is therefore unmet.",
      "durationMs": 167708,
      "artifactIds": [
        "grader-frozen-cases-v1.json",
        "grader-boundary-exact-input-v1.json",
        "grader-boundary-first-screen-projection-v1.txt",
        "grader-boundary-first-screen-v1.png",
        "grader-boundary-observation-projection-v1.json"
      ],
      "conditions": [
        {
          "condition": "The first native response or validation appears within 300 seconds without an account, payment, trial or paid-report action.",
          "verdict": "passed",
          "observed": "The completed first free response was observed within 167708 ms, below 300 seconds; no account, payment, trial or paid report was used. This is an observation upper bound.",
          "evidenceIds": [
            "grader-frozen-cases-v1.json",
            "grader-boundary-exact-input-v1.json",
            "grader-boundary-first-screen-projection-v1.txt",
            "grader-boundary-first-screen-v1.png",
            "grader-boundary-observation-projection-v1.json"
          ]
        },
        {
          "condition": "The response visibly acknowledges that no new technical feature has been supplied or requests that missing feature before assessing it.",
          "verdict": "failed",
          "observed": "The output says there are no distinguishing technical features relative to the primary reference document. That comparison finding does not explicitly acknowledge the supplied statement that no new technical feature was provided. Its later recommendation to check omitted real features follows the numeric assessment, rather than asking for the missing feature before assessing it. The frozen missing-input condition is therefore unmet.",
          "evidenceIds": [
            "grader-frozen-cases-v1.json",
            "grader-boundary-exact-input-v1.json",
            "grader-boundary-first-screen-projection-v1.txt",
            "grader-boundary-first-screen-v1.png",
            "grader-boundary-observation-projection-v1.json"
          ]
        },
        {
          "condition": "No unsupported sensor, electronic display, material, mechanism or experimental performance is attributed to the supplied bottle.",
          "verdict": "passed",
          "observed": "The native answer describes conventional bottle insulation, threaded closure and sealing; it does not attribute a supplied sensor, electronic display, novel material or experiment to this bottle. Suggested future clarification/design directions are not reported as existing input facts.",
          "evidenceIds": [
            "grader-frozen-cases-v1.json",
            "grader-boundary-exact-input-v1.json",
            "grader-boundary-first-screen-projection-v1.txt",
            "grader-boundary-first-screen-v1.png",
            "grader-boundary-observation-projection-v1.json"
          ]
        },
        {
          "condition": "The output does not represent an unsupported novelty score as a definitive conclusion that this generic product is patentable.",
          "verdict": "passed",
          "observed": "The 0/100 result is labeled Anticipated and Not filing-ready, not a definitive finding that the generic bottle is patentable. The retained bounded-screen notice further qualifies the numerical score.",
          "evidenceIds": [
            "grader-frozen-cases-v1.json",
            "grader-boundary-exact-input-v1.json",
            "grader-boundary-first-screen-projection-v1.txt",
            "grader-boundary-first-screen-v1.png",
            "grader-boundary-observation-projection-v1.json"
          ]
        },
        {
          "condition": "The tool makes no guarantee of patent grant or freedom to operate and does not initiate filing or purchase of a report.",
          "verdict": "passed",
          "observed": "The retained notice rejects patent-grant and FTO clearance guarantees. No filing, account, report purchase, marketing email or paid action was initiated.",
          "evidenceIds": [
            "grader-frozen-cases-v1.json",
            "grader-boundary-exact-input-v1.json",
            "grader-boundary-first-screen-projection-v1.txt",
            "grader-boundary-first-screen-v1.png",
            "grader-boundary-observation-projection-v1.json"
          ]
        },
        {
          "condition": "The original two-step input, first response, timing and all checks are retained without filling the gap, repairing the answer or repeating the assessment.",
          "verdict": "passed",
          "observed": "The original missing-feature input, first response, screenshot, timing and frozen conditions remain retained; no missing feature was added, no answer repaired and no assessment repeated.",
          "evidenceIds": [
            "grader-frozen-cases-v1.json",
            "grader-boundary-exact-input-v1.json",
            "grader-boundary-first-screen-projection-v1.txt",
            "grader-boundary-first-screen-v1.png",
            "grader-boundary-observation-projection-v1.json"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "expectedBehaviorReview": {
        "verdict": "failed",
        "observed": "The original expected behavior requires the absent new technical feature to remain explicit through validation, clarification or a qualified inconclusive response. The first output instead assigns 0/100 after conventional-feature comparison without explicitly recognizing the input omission before assessment. Its later check-for-omitted-features advice and screening disclaimer do not satisfy that frozen missing-input requirement. No hallucinated sensor or patentability guarantee is asserted.",
        "evidenceIds": [
          "grader-frozen-cases-v1.json",
          "grader-boundary-exact-input-v1.json",
          "grader-boundary-first-screen-projection-v1.txt",
          "grader-boundary-first-screen-v1.png",
          "grader-boundary-observation-projection-v1.json"
        ]
      }
    }
  ],
  "readonlyFiles": [],
  "audit": {
    "method": "First native UI output retained; primary publication identifiers and sampled quotations independently checked against original documents.",
    "readAttempts": [],
    "blockedActions": [],
    "stagedFilesBefore": [],
    "stagedFilesAfter": [],
    "limitations": [
      "Hidden backend calls, server retrieval activity and models were not observed.",
      "Public UI evidence does not establish host filesystem or Git staging isolation.",
      "Boundary references and unsampled original passages were not independently audited."
    ]
  },
  "usage": {
    "inputTokens": null,
    "outputTokens": null,
    "source": null
  },
  "cost": {
    "amount": null,
    "currency": null,
    "scope": "Native UI marked the assessment free; no payment, trial or paid report. Total compute, service, setup and human-review cost unmeasured."
  }
}