Compare ecommerce customer support agents by knowledge, store actions, handoff, setup, and charging model.
Documentation comparison · Reviewed 2026-10-01 · Hands-on test pending
TASK DECISION · REVIEWED 2026-10-11
Can the agent answer from your policy and hand over the exceptions?
A source-grounded draft reply and the correct handoff decision for each synthetic ticket.
Gorgias AI Agent
Shortlist for a Gorgias helpdesk workflow with explicitly configured commerce actions.
Verify before choosing: Official documentation describes opt-in actions and configurable handover. Check the actual permissions and conditions in your account.
Tidio Lyro
Shortlist for knowledge-based replies with source review and configured escalation.
Verify before choosing: Check uploaded knowledge, the source used for each reply, and online/offline handoff behavior.
What the evidence establishes
Official documentation has been reviewed. No same-input account-level execution is recorded for this pair. The checks below are a proposed evaluation, not completed results.
Accept an output only when these checks pass
Answer the ordinary policy question using the supplied policy only.
Hand off a request for a person, an unresolved policy exception, or an unverified order.
Do not claim a refund, cancellation, or address change occurred without an authorized successful action.
Retain the transcript, source used, handoff destination, and action log for each case.
Stop condition: Stop the pilot if an answer exposes another customer’s information or claims an unexecuted order change.
Use one currency and the same batch period. Enter your actual costs, including failed attempts. This calculator stays in your browser and does not save or send these values.
Formula: (allocated software + usage and other charges + hours × hourly cost) ÷ accepted outputs. This is your estimate, not a vendor price or measured benchmark.
Sources and method
Official product documentation reviewed on 2026-10-11. Feature descriptions are vendor claims; the recorded execution above, where present, has its own date and scope. These hosted products were not reverse engineered or tested with REA.
For open-source agents, our sister site uAgentKit separates source inspection from native execution. Both sites are operated by the same team.
Documentation comparison
Evaluate Gorgias when your support workflow needs its helpdesk and configured commerce actions. Evaluate Lyro when knowledge-based answers and handoff fit your store’s needs. Use the same support test set before choosing.
Workflow and access comparison for Gorgias AI Agent vs Tidio Lyro
Supported order and return actions depend on integration
Supported smart actions depend on connected systems
Human handoff
Configured helpdesk escalation
Configured escalation to the support team
Cost to verify
Helpdesk plus applicable AI usage charges
Plan, conversations, and applicable add-ons
Start with your support stack
If you already use either helpdesk, include migration cost and staff workflow in the decision. If you are starting fresh, list the channels, store integrations, languages, and support actions you require. A long feature list has little value when it does not cover the conversations your customers actually have.
Test answers, actions, and escalation separately
Create questions with answers in your policy, questions with missing information, and requests requiring an order-specific action. Check accuracy first, then verify permissions and identity checks for actions. Finally, confirm that a person receives the conversation with useful context when the agent cannot proceed. This directory has not run that store-level test for either product.
Compare cost at your real conversation volume
Review current pricing definitions, conversation allowances, chargeable resolutions, helpdesk subscriptions, and overage terms. Estimate a normal month and a peak month. Vendor savings claims are not a forecast of your outcome; compare quality, resolved conversations, staff review time, and total cost in a limited pilot.
Current feature availability, integration, and pricing should be confirmed with the vendor. No paid placement or third-party affiliate link is used in this comparison.
Allow cookies to measure visits and tool interactions? We exclude search text and inquiry fields. You can change your choice in Analytics preferences. Privacy notice